I hope the bloke who mistook Kevin Gibbard and Sophie Landers for bandmates at the Shacklewell Arms in Dalston has heard Black Doldrums by now. The pair had met at a sixties psych night and spent years going to gigs and swapping records, so he was defo onto something. When he suggested they start a band, Gibbard even had a few songs they could try. By 2016 the London pair had their own cassette out. Ten years on, Repetition Compulsion completes a trilogy that began with their first Fuzz Club album, Dead Awake, and continued with In Limerence, a record I had the pleasure of writing about here back in the heady days of 2024.
It was Landers who spotted the connection while she was working on the artwork for In Limerence. She recognised feelings in those songs that the pair had explored on the previous record, and her observation gave them the idea for their State of Mind Trilogy. On this final instalment they go as far back as music Gibbard made before the two of them had even met. As he puts it,

“The album invites listeners to confront the echoes of the past while questioning whether those patterns can ever truly be broken.”
Let’s drop the needle and see how this chapter ends.
‘Repetition’ takes its time coming into earshot. The synths sound some distance away at first, each pass bringing them a little closer. Landers eases the drums in underneath and you can just make out Gibbard’s guitar before his voice joins it, blurred at the edges by the effects. The eerie thing is how much seems to be moving towards you while the band are going round the same three chords. I’d have sworn there were more.
Three chords do a different job on ‘The Uncanny’. The pace picks up and Gibbard gives the guitar the bit you’ll be singing. There’s a glint to that little figure that makes it easy to pick out above the darker sound behind it. By the second time round I was waiting for its return in exactly the way I’d usually wait for a chorus. You could sing the whole thing to somebody afterwards without knowing a word.
I’ve had the chorus of ‘Waiting’ going round my head for hours, which made choosing the first of my two favourites a fairly easy business. There’s a wee bit of pop star glamour about Gibbard here. He sings a melody you can follow straight away and still sounds like a man with something left to tell you. I love that air of mystery, especially once you find yourself singing along. If somebody would be good enough to play this one to Robert Smith, I reckon he’d be smitten too.
Gibbard wrote ‘Beat The Rain’ just days after meeting Landers. Knowing that made me smile at how ominous it sounds to begin with. The low synths could pass for a group of monks chanting together, and you could sing a fairly gruesome murder ballad over that guitar part. Then the synth moves up into a higher register for the chorus and there’s real bliss in those notes. I’d love to know what Landers made of that change the first time she heard it.
There’s a live recording of ‘Echoes’ from Belgrade and I’d quite like to have felt that bass coming through the PA. It sounds menacing enough here, worrying away at the same figure while Landers holds a steady motorik beat underneath. Listen to what the synth is up to above the pair of them. There’s a proper goth pop tune going on up there, and by the time I catch myself dancing to it that bass is still at my heels.
Landers worked out most of her drum parts for the album on an electronic kit, where she could try things in her own time. I’d happily listen to her part on ‘Compulsion’ all on its own. She sets up an offbeat shuffle and plays a quick rat a tat across it, leaving the guitar and bass to stretch their notes out over the top. Gibbard sings with real insistence, urging that beat along. He originally wrote this and ‘Repetition’ as one piece. Put the two songs side by side and you can hear how far they’ve grown apart just by following her drums.
The guitar on ‘No One’s Talking To Me’ makes it sound as if somebody’s given Gibbard the keys to a cathedral. The bass is loud enough to get them taken off him again. In amongst that glorious racket Landers picks her moments, playing around the melody so there’s still a little space for the guitar notes to ring. It’s the shortest song here and the whole thing’s over while I’m still bracing myself for the next thump.
Scott Walker came to mind on ‘Bat Bomb’, which is a fair way to travel from those opening bars of European synth pop. There’s one chord change I look forward to every time. The song takes its time getting there, and when that chord comes you can feel how much bigger the melody has become since you first heard it. That’s where I hear the kinship with Walker singing ‘Amsterdam’ in its slow building epicness.
As for the song that shares top spot with ‘Waiting’, ‘No Words Can’t Lie’ had me before the introduction was over. The opening melody has that quality I love in The Cure at their most devastating, where a few beautifully chosen notes can make your heart sore. By now I know what’s coming and it gets me every time. A little way in I realise I’ve sunk right back into my chair, perfectly happy to put off whatever I was about to do.
That mood stays with me through ‘Die With Me’. I get a very particular picture of walking through the woods in winter, seeing a little further between the trees with the leaves off and enjoying the quiet when I stop for a moment. It’s a comforting place to spend time. By the end of the song those three stark words sound rather like the offer of a bit of company.
Long before Black Doldrums had a trilogy to finish, Gibbard had the tune for ‘Eulogy’. He found the instrumental in a box of cassettes he’d recorded in his bedroom when he was young. The band give it the longest stretch on the album, and I’m glad they do. Its slow, melancholy pace leaves you time to sit with what these songs have meant to you. What would the lad who first played that tune make of hearing it now, with Landers beside him and a whole history between them?
What’s stayed with me about Repetition Compulsion is how differently I feel about hearing something come round again by the time the record finishes. There’s unease in those first three chords. By ‘Eulogy’ it seems to me the kindest thing you could do for an old tune is give it another go in good company. Landers has given me a reason to play all three albums in order and see what else she heard connecting them. For now, I keep putting this one on to settle which of my two favourites I like best. I’m getting quite fond of the habit.
Repetition Compulsion is out now via Fuzz Club. You can check it out over on the Black Doldrums Bandcamp page.


You can follow Black Doldrums on social media here…
Discover more from Static Sounds Club
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.